3 Review(s)

Most authors feel that as a result of the changes made by the editors, their works might appear less than brilliant. A good editor is able to convince the authors that their genius would be obscured minus the editorial revisions. Editors do not deny that the subject matter of the manuscript is the author\'s jurisdiction, but its presentation or organization and \'packaging\', as Arthur Plotnik calls it, is the speciality of the editor. The editor who shows due regards to the author\'s knowledge of the subject and is able to explain this dichotomy to him, succeeds in making the author to submit to his ways in matters of \'packaging\'. Arthur Plotnik told a group authors that the reason for their being was \'communication\' and not nourishment of ego, praise of colleagues, money, or the love of generations to come. “You write to communicate to the hearts and minds of others what\'s burning inside you” and we edit to let the “fire show through the smoke”. The editor should take utmost care to preserve the author\'s originality. His job is to give a proper shape to the style in which the author\'s ideas have been presented, not to the ideas themselves. Every individual has his own style of expression that imparts it individuality. If the editor smothers the author\'s style, his individuality, it becomes ghost- writing, not editing. About the Author Dr Anup Taneja is one of the editors of the reputed research journal, The Indian Historical Review. He has been associated with the editing of this journal for more than 28 years. He topped the editing group of the PGD in Book Publishing Examination (a two-year course) of the University of Delhi in 1993. He has taught editing at the post-graduate level at the Faculty of Book Publishing, CVS, University of Delhi, from 1993 to 2000. He has also worked as Publications Secretary, Siddha Yoga Dham, New Delhi, from 1973 to 1981. His published works include: Breaking out of Invisibility: Women in Indian History, 2002 (edited in collaboration with Prof. Aparna Basu); Sufi Cults and the Evolution of Medieval Indian Cultural, 2003 (edited); and Gandhi, Women, and the National Movement, 1920-47 (2005).